at fault driver not enough insurance california

What Happens If the At-Fault Driver Doesn’t Have Enough Insurance in California?

Picture a crash that leaves you with $90,000 in medical bills, two months of missed work, and a car that is a total loss. The other driver clearly caused it. Then you learn their policy only carries the California minimum of $30,000 for one injured person. The math does not work, and suddenly a straightforward claim feels like a dead end.

This situation is far more common than most drivers realize. The good news is that a low policy limit on the other side is rarely the end of the story. Depending on your own coverage and the facts of the crash, there may be several other ways to close the gap. Here is what happens when the at-fault driver doesn’t have enough insurance in California, and what you can do about it.

at fault driver not enough insurance california

What Counts as an Underinsured Driver?

An underinsured driver has liability insurance, but not enough of it to cover the full cost of the harm they caused. That is different from an uninsured driver, who has no coverage at all. We cover that scenario in our article on what to do after an accident with an uninsured driver in California.

The difference matters because underinsured claims follow a specific sequence. In most cases, the at-fault driver’s insurer pays first, up to its policy limit, and then other sources of recovery come into play.

California’s Minimum Insurance Limits

California raised its minimum auto liability limits on January 1, 2025. According to a California Department of Insurance bulletin on SB 1107, the current minimums are as follows.

  • $30,000 for bodily injury or death of one person
  • $60,000 for bodily injury or death of two or more people in one accident
  • $15,000 for property damage

Those numbers are double the old 15/30/5 limits, but they still fall short in many injury cases. A single emergency room visit, an MRI, and a few months of physical therapy can approach or exceed $30,000 before lost income, future care, or pain and suffering are even considered. We explain those categories in detail in our guide to the types of damages you can recover in a personal injury case.

Step One Is Usually the At-Fault Driver’s Policy

The first source of compensation is normally the liability policy of the driver who caused the crash. If your losses clearly exceed their limits, their insurer may offer the full policy amount, sometimes called a policy limits settlement.

Before accepting, it is important to understand what you are signing. A release given to the at-fault driver’s insurer can affect your ability to pursue other sources, including your own underinsured motorist coverage. Your own insurer may need to be notified and given a chance to respond before you settle. This is one of the many details adjusters rarely explain, which is why we wrote about what insurance companies don’t want you to know.

How Underinsured Motorist Coverage Works

Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage is part of your own auto policy. It is designed for exactly this situation. When the at-fault driver’s limits are too low, UIM coverage may help pay the difference, up to the limits you purchased.

There are a few important points about how UIM generally works in California.

  • It is usually offset. The amount paid by the at-fault driver’s insurer is typically credited against your UIM limit. If you carry $100,000 in UIM coverage and the other driver’s insurer paid $30,000, the remaining UIM amount available is generally up to $70,000.
  • Your limits need to be higher than theirs. If your UIM limit is the same as the at-fault driver’s liability limit, there may be nothing left to collect after the offset.
  • Disputes may go to arbitration. When you and your own insurer disagree about the value of a UIM claim, California law generally sends that dispute to arbitration rather than a jury trial.
  • Notice and deadlines matter. UIM claims come with their own notice requirements and time limits, which can differ from the standard deadline for suing the at-fault driver.

It can feel strange to make a claim against your own insurance company, but an underinsured motorist claim is still adversarial. Your insurer has a financial interest in paying as little as possible. Our page on dealing with car insurance adjusters covers tactics to watch for.

insurance agent inspecting damaged car after accident

Other Possible Sources of Compensation

Even without UIM coverage, there may be other parties or policies that can help. A careful investigation looks at every potential source, including the following.

Other Responsible Parties

Some crashes involve more than one at-fault party. A second negligent driver, a company whose employee was driving for work, a vehicle owner who allowed an unsafe driver to use the car, or a government agency responsible for a dangerous road condition may share responsibility. Claims involving public entities have very short deadlines, so they need prompt attention.

Commercial and Rideshare Policies

If the at-fault driver was working at the time, an employer’s commercial policy may apply. Rideshare drivers can be covered by large policies depending on whether the app was on and a ride was in progress. Learn more on our Uber and Lyft accident lawyer page and our truck accident lawyer page.

Umbrella Policies

Some drivers carry a personal umbrella policy that sits on top of their auto coverage. These policies are not always obvious at first and may need to be uncovered through investigation.

Your Own Medical Payments Coverage and Health Insurance

Medical payments coverage on your auto policy and your health insurance can help with treatment costs while the larger claim is pending. These benefits may come with reimbursement rights, so it helps to understand how they fit into the overall recovery.

The At-Fault Driver’s Personal Assets

In theory, a driver can be personally responsible for a judgment above their policy limits. In practice, many minimum-limit drivers do not have significant collectible assets, so this option needs a realistic evaluation before it is pursued.

Common Mistakes That Can Reduce Your Recovery

  • Accepting a quick policy limits offer and signing a release without understanding its effect on other claims
  • Not notifying your own insurer of a potential underinsured motorist claim
  • Giving a recorded statement to an adjuster before speaking with an attorney
  • Waiting too long to investigate other responsible parties or public entity claims
  • Stopping or delaying medical care, which can make injuries look less serious than they are
  • Posting about the crash or your recovery online, which we cover in how social media posts can affect your personal injury case

injured man arm sling reviewing medical forms

How to Protect Yourself Before the Next Crash

The best time to think about underinsured drivers is before an accident happens. Review your own policy and look at the following.

  • Your UIM limits. Many drivers carry the lowest UIM limits offered without realizing it. Higher limits often cost less than people expect.
  • Medical payments coverage. This optional coverage can help with immediate treatment costs regardless of fault.
  • Umbrella coverage. If you have significant assets or simply want extra protection, an umbrella policy may also extend uninsured and underinsured coverage, depending on its terms.

Only you and your insurance agent can decide what coverage is right for your budget, but knowing the gap exists is the first step to closing it.

Why the Order of Steps Matters

Underinsured claims are less about one big decision and more about a sequence of smaller ones made in the right order. Notifying the right insurers, preserving evidence, documenting your losses, and identifying every potential source of coverage all need to happen before key settlement papers are signed. A misstep early on can limit what is available later.

That is a big reason why many people choose to speak with an attorney when the other driver’s coverage looks too small. If you are unsure whether you need help, our article on when to hire a personal injury attorney in Orange County can help you decide.

injured client meeting car accident lawyer

Talk to an Orange County Car Accident Lawyer

If you were hurt by a driver whose insurance will not cover your losses, Russell & Lazarus can review your situation, identify every available source of compensation, and handle communication with the insurance companies on your behalf. Our car accident lawyers have represented injured Californians for more than 25 years, and you can review some of our car accident case results.

Call (877) 789-4878 or contact us online for a free consultation. For a broader overview of the process, you can also read our car accident guide.

Frequently Asked Questions About Underinsured Drivers in California

What happens if the other driver only has minimum insurance in California?

Their insurer generally pays up to the policy limit, which is currently $30,000 per injured person for bodily injury. If your losses are higher, you may be able to recover the difference through your own underinsured motorist coverage, other responsible parties, or other available policies.

Is underinsured motorist coverage required in California?

Insurers must offer uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, but you can decline it in writing. Check your declarations page to see whether you have it and what your limits are.

Will my rates go up if I file an underinsured motorist claim?

California generally limits an insurer’s ability to raise your rates for an accident you did not cause. If you have questions about your specific policy, ask your agent or insurer directly.

Can I sue the at-fault driver for more than their policy limits?

Yes, a driver can be personally responsible for damages above their coverage. Whether that is worthwhile depends on whether the driver has assets that can realistically be collected, which should be evaluated carefully before pursuing that route.

Should I accept the at-fault driver’s policy limits offer?

A policy limits offer may be appropriate, but the release you sign can affect other claims, including your underinsured motorist claim. Speak with an attorney and notify your own insurer before signing anything.

How long do I have to file a claim after a car accident in California?

The general deadline for a personal injury lawsuit in California is two years, but claims against government agencies and underinsured motorist claims can have different and sometimes much shorter requirements. Read more in our article on the car accident statute of limitations in California.

Do I need a lawyer for an underinsured motorist claim?

You are not required to have one, but UIM claims involve offsets, notice rules, and arbitration with your own insurer. An experienced attorney can help you avoid mistakes that reduce your recovery.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different, so please contact an attorney about your specific situation.

Receive A Complimentary Case Evaluation

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.